Amendment 1
Today I voted. What a great feeling.
Another great feeling was voting NO on amendment 1.
Today I gave a speech in my Comm. 240 class on the amendment.
Here it is:
“This sort of marriage is not in the best interest of children.” “God has a plan for marriage and this isn’t it.” “Allowing this kind of marriage will pave the way for all sorts of moral depravity.” Comments from the 1960s on the interracial marriage of one man and one woman -- Mildred Jeter and Richard Loving.
“Love has many shapes and colors and is not finite. It can not be measured or defined in terms of sexual orientation." From a Quaker meeting in Aotearoa.
Marriage has always been an issue in this country. Who we can and cannot marry has changed numerous times since the founding of America. Next month, Tennessee voters will have a chance to change history. Voters will be asked to consider a referendum on an amendment to the state constitution regarding same sex marriage. By the end of this speech, I hope to educate each of you on the significance of this amendment and why we should vote no. I will do this by explaining the amendment itself, discussing arguments for the amendment, and giving arguments against it.
The Amendment: (as it appears on the ballot)
The historical institution and legal contract solemnizing the relationship of one man and one woman shall be the only legally recognized marital contract in this state. Any policy or law or judicial interpretation, purporting to define marriage as anything other than the historical institution and legal contract between one man and one woman, is contrary to the public policy of this state and shall be void and unenforceable in Tennessee. If another state or foreign jurisdiction issues a license for persons to marry and if such marriage is prohibited in this state by the provisions of this section, then the marriage shall be void and unenforceable in this state.
- would permanently deny equal marriage rights to Tennessee’s same-sex couples
- According to the 2000 US Census, are 20,378 people.
- Similar amendments in other states have been used to justify denial of domestic partner benefits at state institutions and agencies to heterosexual as well as same-sex couples
- TN Constitution- amended very few times
- 1st time it would be restricting rights instead of granting them
2. Arguments FOR the amendment (against SSM)
1. Gay marriage goes against our country’s foundation.
- When most refer to the foundation of our country, they mean the
constitution and the government
- As a nation we have made many changes to the “foundation” of our country:
- abolishment of slavery
- suffrage movement
- Without these changes, where would we be now?
2. In the past, homosexuals have not been allowed to marry.
- until a few decades ago, we did not allow people of different races to marry. Before that, in some states, we did not allow African-American slaves to marry. The institution of marriage has been in a continual state of flux for centuries.
3. The introduction of legalized gay marriages will lead inexorably to
polygamy and other alternatives to one-man, one-woman unions.
- Allowing two persons of the same sex to marry is one decision. Allowing more than two persons to marry is a separate decision. There is no cause-and-effect relationship between the two. A government could approve of neither, of both, or of one without the other. They are independent expansions to the traditional concept of marriage.
4. The implications for children in a world of decaying families are profound.
- Few studies have been done comparing homosexual couples to heterosexual couples in the area of child rearing
- (Judge Kevin Chang) Hawaii:
- “There is a diversity in the structure and configuration of families" today, including single parents, divorced parents, stepparents, adoptive parents and gay and lesbian parents. "The evidence presented establishes that the single most important factor in the development of a happy, healthy and well-adjusted child is the nurturing relationship between parent and child."
5. Marriage is a sacrament designed by God
- 1st amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances
- This amendment would not force churches to allow same sex marriages. That would be up to each individual church
6. Marriage is DEFINED as a union between a man and a woman
- Definitions of marriage:
i. Socially-approved sexual and economic union, usually of a male and a female, that is assumed to be more or less permanent.
ii. A contractually committed partnership, including sexual love, cohabitation, shared economy/property and mutual childrearing
iii. A marriage is a relationship between or among individuals, usually recognized by civil authority and/or bound by the religious beliefs of the participants. The fact that marriage often has the dual nature of a binding legal contract plus a moral promise can make it difficult to characterize.
7. Homosexuals choose to be gay.
- According to the American Psychological Association, when asked if
people choose to be gay:
- No, human beings cannot choose to be either gay or straight. For most people, sexual orientation emerges in early adolescence without any prior sexual experience. Although we can choose whether to act on our feelings, psychologists do not consider sexual orientation to be a conscious choice that can be voluntarily changed.
3. Arguments AGAINST the amendment (for SSM)
- Marriage and civil unions would be a basic human right.
- Who can argue with this?
- Ask anyone if they feel that every person in America should have the same rights, and they will most likely answer yes.
- Abbey Rubbenfeld: “I can understand why adults cannot marry children, why adults cannot marry close relatives, why adults cannot marry animals, but I cannot understand why a competent adult cannot marry another competent adult.”
- Homosexual people would be able to share in the rights and privileges that married people have now.
- According to a report given to the Office of the General Counsel of the U.S. General Accounting Office, there are 1,049 benefits the United States government provides to legally married couples:
Access to Military Stores
Assumption of Spouse’s Pension
Bereavement Leave
Immigration
Insurance Breaks
Medical Decisions on Behalf of Partner
Social Security Survivor Benefits
Sick Leave to Care for Partner
Tax Breaks
Veteran’s Discounts
Visitation of Partner in Hospital or Prison
- Many people disagree with this amendment:
- Over 34 faith leaders from various churches
- Over 9 entire church congregations (Metropolitan Community Church, Knoxville)
- Over 9 newspapers (including the Nashville Tennesseean)
- Over 41 organizations and businesses around TN
- ALL have spoken out against this amendment.
- If you still are not convinced, think about this: if the amendment does not pass, same sex marriage will not be legal.
In conclusion, I would ask that everyone that is able to vote in the upcoming election on November seventh, do so. I hope that after learning about the amendment itself, hearing arguments for it, and listening to arguments against it, when you get into the voting booth and see amendment one, you will vote no.
Let’s make history in Tennessee, our nation, and the world.